‘Sustaining spaces where Black workers can come together’
RACISM affects every journalist who is labelled as belonging to a minority – who is racialised. What can the union do to help combat its corrosive effects? At our meeting on 12 October we heard from Roger Mackenzie, chair of the NUJ Black Members Council, and Michelle Codrington-Rogers, Anti-Racism Policy Lead at the Trades Union Congress (TUC).

Michelle Codrington-Rogers
We invited Michelle to describe its impact on Black workers, on the trade union movement and within our wider society. She notes that the TUC Black Workers' Conference (BWC) in April had just under 360 attendees from across the trade union movement.
“When I was a citizenship teacher, I taught about social media, broadcast media, press, and their impact, not just on our society, but on the political will and forward thinking of our society and our communities.
“We're seeing attacks on sectors of the media which have reputations for being ethical or for trying to get the stories out. But we're also seeing these self-designated ‘citizen reporters’, bad-faith actors, agitators, often people who have got very strong links to the far right.”
The BWC “received motions – from, obviously, the NUJ, and from the Fire Brigades Union (FBU) and the Royal College of Podiatrists – raising concerns around the impact of the media and giving support to those members who work in press and in broadcasting who are trying to do the right thing, to create spaces in our society where we can have honest conversations without allowing them to get hijacked by bad-faith actors – in this particular case, the far right.
“All three motions were supported. They mentioned [the NUJ’s demand for] a conscience clause, and clause 12 [of the Editors' Code of Practice, which deals with discrimination].
“We have to, as British society, for the first thing, we've got to be really careful that what happened to Professor Jason Arday in such a public way doesn't become routinised. His family want their time to mourn, they want their time to reflect, they want their time as they're he lost his identity and became a sign.
“We have to recognise that he wasn't protected as a black worker by his employer.
“Black workers stand behind conscientious and ethical, media. But we also recognise that work has to be done to protect our communities, and especially those members of our communities who have got a profile, whether it was sought or not.
“You guys are at the forefront of this pushback against the far right exploiting the instruments of information that we depend on. How can we work together to make sure that the Black community feels seen, but also feel protected, whilst also protecting you – and your Black colleagues, when they are trying to get the stories out that we need?”

Roger Mackenzie
Roger McKenzie opened by welcoming all the new members of the NUJ who had joined that evening. “You've joined an important movement, the trade union movement, which has never been more needed than it is now, to deal with the sort of things that Michelle has talked about. That requires a strong trade union movement. It needs a to deal with the issues that Michelle talked about in relation to the media.
“We need a stronger NUJ. Our membership is not strong enough to deal with some of these ruthless employers that are out there. It's really important that we recognise the importance of having people around who are prepared to stand up for trade unionism, because, in too many places, it's still seen as being something that will upset management, and particularly for you folks who are freelances and may ask: will I still get the work that I need to be able to keep a roof over my family's heads? Will I still be able to put food on the table?
“Without a strong trade union movement to assert ourselves, with, with the employer, we're going to find it much more difficult to make progress. Michelle's right: it's not just about the far right, it's about a rising racism, even among people who wouldn't necessarily associate themselves with the far right.
I'm old enough to remember 1968, when Enoch Powell made his “rivers of blood” speech. I was born and brought up just up the road from where he made that speech [in Birmingham]. I remember that I started school just after that speech. I remember, for the first year, as a 5-year-old, my 6-year-old brother and I were getting harassed every single morning as we tried to go to school, getting kicked and spat at.
“Then at school we had to deal with teachers who didn't give a toss, frankly, about what we were experiencing, and actually gave us some of that same stuff as well.
“Later we got new laws [against racial discrimination]. We may often win new laws, as when Stephen Lawrence was murdered.
“When George Floyd was killed in the States, there was a whole awakening, around ‘what you must be going through, as black people’. An injury to one is an injury to all: that old saying is really true.
“If they can create divisions between black and white workers, or people who are English, or Polish, or German, or French, or whatever, they can drive down wages.
“I am reminded, of the work of Claudia Jones - a pioneering journalist who exposed the racism that was taking place on the ground. We were lucky enough, last year to have Michelle as one of our speakers at the Claudia Jones lecture. We're going to have an absolutely standing-room-only Claudia Jones Lecture next week.
“Claudia was one of the people responsible for getting the Notting Hill Carnival off the ground. She was a pioneering black woman journalist.
“Clearly a load of people who are of colour, who are black, have joined the union this evening. That's wonderful. But we have to ask: are they being restricted to being freelances? Are they not getting an opportunity to get into full-time, employment with broadcast outlets or newspapers?
“This is by far the most diverse NUJ meeting that I've ever attended, other than the Black Members’ Council. I think you should congratulate yourselves for that, but we should also ask, what is it about freelancing that means that this is where Black workers are?
“Not everybody thinks that anti-racism is something that we should be involved in, even though, frankly, for me, that's a basic tenet of trade unionism. When we were calling out some of these characters, Tommy Robinson, for example, and the role that he's played, and somebody said to we shouldn't name and shame these people, you know?
“We have to go and cover these far-right demonstrations, and we'll be picked on. If we believe in anti-racism, then we should go out and organise and fight for it, and not be ashamed. To be anti-racist, for me, it's a bigger issue than a trade union issue. It's about being divided against each other and arguing with each other while people are making loads of profits off our back.
“Thank you for inviting me, this evening. It is Black History Month, and I'm not a great fan of Black History Month, to be honest, because I think Black History is 365 days a year.”
Questions and observations
Nisar Ali Shah spoke of being “depressed” by the media coverage of Jason Arday. “Silicon Valley billionaire Peter Thiel influenced Cambridge University and targeted Jason. The ferocity of his demonisation and the pressure he had to go through was too intense to endure: 249 articles were published about him in a space of three weeks. It eventually killed him.
Mick Holder spoke of the importance of trades councils: “We need to move locally as well as nationally. I mean, it is ridiculous, the number of people that are turning out for far-right demonstrations. But after the Portsmouth anti-migrant protests, when they decided that they were going to attack the RNLI [Royal National Lifeboat Institution], donations to the RNLI apparently went through the roof.”
Deborah Hobson commented on Michelle’s mention of bad-faith “citizen reporting” by far-right propagandists and Tommy Robinson [Stephen Yaxley-Lennon] assuming that title: “I'm a freelance journalist, I've worked for mainstream and independent media, but I'm also a champion of citizen journalism. That sort of reporting has a very good tradition. If we remember what, happened with the murder of George Floyd in 2020, if it wasn't for the filming by a young black woman who witnessed his murder by a white policeman the world would not have been aware of what happened there. That spawned the global Black Lives Matter movement, and also led to the prosecution of that police officer.
“We know that the mainstream media now use citizen reporting as user-generated content. Often, those producers are not being credited, not being given a byline and not being paid. But we wouldn't know some of the terrible things that have happened in the world, or going on, if it wasn't for our citizen reporting, and it's a pity that the title has been hijacked by people like Tommy Robinson.”
Roger responded that he “agrees entirely with Deborah about citizen journalism. There's a really strong track record of people getting involved in it.”
Michelle concluded by stressing the need for “building and creating and sustaining spaces where Black workers can come together… to help carry on your journey within the trade union movement so that you can take up your rightful place in our community and our family of Black activists who support each other and look out for each other.”
![[Freelance]](../gif/fl3H.png)